The Coffee House
Garlan Tyrell vs Aragorn - Printable Version

+- The Coffee House (https://tch-forum.com)
+-- Forum: Off-Topic (https://tch-forum.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=50)
+--- Forum: RPGs and Fantasies (https://tch-forum.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=56)
+---- Forum: Face-off Arena (https://tch-forum.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=32)
+---- Thread: Garlan Tyrell vs Aragorn (/showthread.php?tid=3432)



Garlan Tyrell vs Aragorn - JHG - 05-15-2019

Garlan Tyrell
[Image: Garlan_Tyrell_by_cloudninja9.jpg]
The humble middle of the Sons of Lord Tyrell, Garlan the Gallant is a formidable fighter.
Abilities: >average physical abilities, excellent swordsmanship, charisma
Aragorn
[Image: John_Howe_-_Elessar.jpg]
He may seem like a typical Ranger but he’s actually the heir to the Kingdoms of Númenor.
Abilities: superhuman physical abilities, longevity, charisma, excellent swordsmanship, great archery, tracking, great senses
Round 1: Regular match.
Round 2: Garlan has full plate but Aragorn is clothed and unarmored.


RE: Garlan Tyrell vs Aragorn - Kyng - 05-15-2019

Aragorn, and I don't even think it'd be close.

"Superhuman physical abilities" beats "above average physical abilities"; they both have excellent swordsmanship; Garlan Tyrell's charisma won't matter; and Aragorn has a whole bunch of abilities that he doesn't on top of that.


RE: Garlan Tyrell vs Aragorn - JHG - 05-16-2019

For the record, not all superhuman abilities are created equal; Aragorn is way below the caliber of Starfire for example. I just prefer to be concise in the descriptions.
And yes, Aragorn would win although Andúril might have a little difficulty with Garlan’s armor. Keep in mind many Men of the Reach wear plate armor.


RE: Garlan Tyrell vs Aragorn - Kyng - 05-16-2019

Well, since it doesn't look like a particularly close fight, what advantages could be given to Garlan to give him more of a chance? (For example, would a team-mate help, or would that make his side too powerful?)


RE: Garlan Tyrell vs Aragorn - JHG - 05-19-2019

Ok, Round 2. Garlan has a suit of full plate but Aragorn is in his ranger clothing.